 |
Caught in a Loop:
Many Suffer Shame of OCD Needlessly
By Stephanie Sampson, M.A.
A man always locks
his apartment door in the same order every night. He won't get out of bed
without tapping his slippers first. Germs freak him out. He must carefully
negotiate walking down the street because he can't step on any cracks in the
sidewalk.
Recognize him? It
is Jack Nicholson's character in "As Good as It Gets," a man with
Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD).
"Not only did
the movie increase awareness about OCD-the tapping, checking and fear of contamination-but
it really showed the shame associated with the disorder and how it interferes
with relationships and daily living," says Gail Steketee, Ph.D., assistant
professor at Boston University's School of Social Work.
About 1 in 50 Americans
suffers from OCD, although they may not be diagnosed for years.
"As a result, too many people suffer needlessly from this very treatable
disorder," says Steketee.
Neatnik or Something Else?
But why wouldn't Nicholson's character just be considered a perfectionist
or neatnik? "As in many other anxiety disorders, the issue is first,
do you have the symptoms of the disorder, and second, to what degree do those
symptoms interfere with your life," says Steketee. "While we all
clean, arrange, and check sometimes in some situations, people with OCD 'have'
to do those things and they do them constantly."
As the name suggests,
OCD is characterized by two main symptoms: obsessions and compulsions. Obsessions
are recurring thoughts, impulses, or images a person experiences (at least
at first) as intrusive or senseless. Common obsessions include thoughts about
contamination, about doing harm to others, persistent doubts about having
performed certain tasks such as turning off appliances, or an extreme need
for orderliness.
Compulsions are repeated
behaviors or physical or mental rituals designed to relieve the discomfort
of the obsessive thoughts (unfortunately that relief is only temporary). Some
of the most common compulsions are cleaning, washing, checking, repeating
actions, being excessively slow and methodical, and hoarding. Mental rituals
include praying, listing things in your head, and rearranging certain words
or phrases in your head.
About 80% of OCD sufferers
have both obsessions and compulsions, but a person may have only one symptom
and still suffer from OCD. Ironically, most people with OCD recognize their
obsessions are coming from within themselves and that their compulsions are
excessive and unreasonable (e.g., checking whether the door is locked will
not protect your children from becoming sick). To meet diagnostic criteria
for OCD, symptoms must take up a lot of time (more than an hour a day) or
significantly interfere with the person's work, social life, or relationships.
OCD symptoms may wax and wane over time.
Also key in OCD is
the link between the obsessions and the compulsions. "While everyone
has had intrusive or obsessive thoughts in their life, in OCD those thoughts
are attached with unpleasant feelings like anxiety, guilt or disgust, and
the person has to do certain things (compulsions) to relieve those feelings,"
says Steketee.
Onset of OCD is usually
gradual and most often begins in adolescence or early adulthood. In fact,
about one-third to one-half of adults with OCD report that the disorder actually
began in childhood.
The Hidden Disorder
Unfortunately, OCD often goes unrecognized for years. The lag time between
beginning of symptoms and appropriate treatment may be as long as 17 years,
according to Eric Hollander, M.D., professor of Psychiatry and Director of
the Compulsive, Impulsive and Anxiety Disorders Program at Mt. Sinai School
of Medicine in New York. What accounts for that lag time? The first reason
is stigma. "Many people with OCD are ashamed and humiliated by what they
consider the bizarre nature of their obsessive thoughts," says Hollander.
"Also they usually recognize that checking or washing or hoarding will
not in reality change anything, but they feel powerless to stop. As a result,
they are less likely to share their problem with a family member or their
doctor."
Second, OCD may not
be the most obvious diagnosis. "Patients often come into their doctor's
office complaining of depression or anxiety," says Hollander. (About
two-thirds of OCD patients have suffered at least one bout of depression in
their lives.) "Unless the physician or therapist is thinking about the
possibility of OCD, they won't ask the right questions and the diagnosis isn't
made."
Getting Better
Research over the last 15 years has shown both medication and specific kinds
of psycho-social treatments to be effective in treating OCD. But getting better
requires a commitment from everyone involved.
"Treatment succeeds
when there is motivation to change," says Hollander. "Because of
the shame and humiliation of this disorder, one of the first steps is awareness
and education," he says. Both the patient and his or her family need
to improve their understanding of:
-
The nature of
the disorder. OCD is a medical problem involving dysfunction of certain
brain chemicals. It is not a character flaw, nor a reflection on the quality
of the person.
-
Treatment options.
During the last 20 years, two effective treatments for OCD have been developed:
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and treatment with medications known
as Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors (SSRIs). About 60-70% of OCD
patients can be helped with existing treatments, according to experts.
-
Role of the patient.
OCD will not go away by itself. "Patients start getting better when
they realize they have to face their fears and that the increased anxiety
that often accompanies treatment won't last forever," says Hollander.
Family support is also key to keeping sufferers motivated to stay with their
treatment (see p. x, "What Family Members Can Do").
CBT helps people change
their thoughts and feelings by first changing their behavior. Behavior therapy
for OCD involves Exposure and Response Prevention. Exposure is based on the
fact that anxiety usually goes down after repeated contact with a feared object.
For exposure to be of the most help, it needs to be combined with response
or ritual prevention. In the latter, the person's rituals or avoidance behaviors
are blocked. For example, a person with OCD may be asked to touch a toilet
seat that he considers contaminated (exposure) and then resist washing his
hands afterwards (ritual prevention). As therapy progresses, the patient is
asked to resist the compulsion for longer and longer periods of time. "Homework"
assignments are given so that the patient can practice with real-life situations
that he or she encounters at home and on the job.
Cognitive Therapy,
the other component of CBT, is often added to Exposure and Response Prevention
to help reduce the catastrophic thinking and exaggerated sense of responsibility
typical of OCD. "People with OCD 'jump to conclusions' about what is
going to happen. For example, a mother might assume that simply having a thought
about hurting her child means that she will do it, but in fact it is only
a thought and actually a pretty common one," says Steketee. "In
cognitive therapy, the patient is asked to pay attention to her thoughts and
beliefs and to evaluate how rational or logical that 'conclusion' really is."
Steketee uses several
exercises to help patients correct their faulty thinking. "For example,
for any given scenario, we ask what the patient would think if a friend argued
that such-and-such would happen. If someone believes they'll cause harm to
their family, we ask them to play judge and jury and logically think about
whether their case would stand up in a court of law."
In milder OCD, CBT
alone is often the initial choice, but medication may also be needed if CBT
is not effective enough. Individuals with severe OCD or complicating conditions
that may interfere with CBT (e.g., panic disorder, depression) often need
to start with medication, adding CBT once the medicine has provided some relief.
SSRIs are the type of medication most often prescribed initially for OCD.
"Research shows that a combination of these two types of treatment results
in the best outcome," says Hollander. However, the doctor may start with
one or the other treatment first, and add the second one later. Whichever
route you and your doctor decide on, experts advise that you:
-
Give medication
a fair trial. A substantial body of evidence shows drugs are highly
effective in OCD. However, patients need patience. "It may take up
to three months to see the effect of an SSRI," warns Hollander. "Waiting
is difficult but you need to give the medicine time to work before giving
up on it." It's also important to follow your doctor's orders on how
much medication to take and when to take it. If you are not happy with your
initial experience, your doctor can try changing the dose, switching to
a different drug, or combining drugs. Do not reduce or increase the amount
you take without specific instructions from your doctor.
-
Manage expectations
about treatment. Knowing what to expect during treatment makes going
through it easier. For example, anxiety often increases during exposure
therapy, and learning that you can get through it OK takes a few trials.
Medication may take a while to kick in. "Although family members may
assume that their loved one's irrational thinking and behaviors should just
stop, recovery is in reality a step-by-step process that takes time,"
says Steketee.
- Take advantage of support networks.
Keeping motivated throughout treatment is always a challenge. Participating
in self-help groups, finding a buddy for exposure "homework," seeking
out books or Internet sites on OCD, and going to family therapy are some of
the many ways to gain insight the recovery process.
- Report changes in symptoms.
Symptoms may arise or increase in intensity for a number of reasons and may
require adjusting treatment. Medications, although safe, do have side effects
(be sure to report any to your doctor). Depression and other anxiety disorders
may co-exist with OCD. Talk to your doctor if you begin to eat or sleep too
much or too little, feel constantly lethargic or hopeless or have suicidal
thoughts. Stress can also exacerbate OCD symptoms.
|
How
Family Members Can Help
- Educate yourself
about the disorder and about available treatments. Helping the person
to understand that there are treatments that can help is a big step
toward getting the person into treatment. In some cases, it may help
to hold a family meeting to discuss the problem. When your family member
is in treatment, talk with the clinician if possible. You could offer
to visit the clinician with the person to share your observations about
how the treatment is going. Encourage the patient to stick with medications
and/or CBT.
- Consider therapy
for the family as a whole. OCD symptoms can cause a great deal of disruption
and the way families react to the symptoms can affect the disorder.
A therapist can help family members learn how to gradually disengage
from the rituals in small steps and learn to manage the distress that
results.
q Watch what you say. Negative comments or criticism from family members
often make OCD worse, while a calm, supportive family can help improve
the outcome of treatment..
- Be on the alert
for signs of relapse. You may notice a reoccurrence of OCD symptoms
before the person does. Point out the early symptoms in a caring manner
and suggest a discussion with the doctor. Learn to tell the difference
between a bad day and OCD, however.
- Make time for
yourself. Try to keep up those routines and activities that keep you
physically and emotionally well. Have family members take turns in checking
in on the person so that no one person is the "caretaker."
SOURCE: Adapted
from Obsessive-Compulsive Foundation website at www.ocfoundation.org |
What Family Members Can (and Shouldn't) Say
| Not Helpful |
Helpful |
| Oh, that's ridiculous |
OK, let's talk about it. |
There's nothing there.
|
Did you actually see any pieces of glass? |
Forget about it.
|
Sit a moment and relax. |
You're slipping
|
Why don't you wait a bit and see how you feel then. |
Not this again!
|
It's not OK to wash just to make sure. That only gets you
into trouble. |
I don't want to hear about it
|
I understand how you might feel that way. |
| That's crazy |
What are the realistic chances that someone might
get hurt? |
SOURCE:
Adapted from When Once is Not Enough: Help for Obsessive Compulsives by Gail
Steketee, Ph.D.
and Kerrin White, M.D. (New Harbinger Publications, Oakland, CA, 1990), p. 129-130
|
|
|
 |